You should offer warm desserts, such as warm chocolate chip cookies or brownies on the MTO menu. It would be quick, easy and inexpensive (you already offer cookies and have the appliances to heat them up)! Warm cookies are definitely trending and I think it would be a great addition to the menu.
Sell smaller cookies. I like the Sheetz cookies, but I don't like that they are 500 calories each... That equals an entire meal worth of calories. I would like to have a smaller cookie option in the 200-250 calorie range.
Right now you have cookies and donuts given separate credits. Why? They are about the same price. Put them together so we can get our rewards sooner, and also add gobs into that, since they are the same price too.
It would be really great to see some allergen free options on your menu or stocked on the shelves. A gluten free, dairy free bread option would be so nice. Or maybe you could offer an allergen free candy bar or pack of cookies? (Enjoy Life has some great tasting allergen free choices!) When traveling, we would certainly stop at a place where we could get an allergen free treat!!
Whatever happened to the Pink-Iced Cookies that used to be sold in the Schweetz section? Seriously, these were my prime motivation for stopping at as many Sheetz as I could! I love the pink cookies with a cappuchino! No where else can you find a cookie of this caliber and there was no reason as to why they were taken away. I've tweeted, Facebooked and e-mailed about these and no one seems fit to respond.
One of my favorite parts about the MTO menu is the drink section. I love the many different options there are for blended coffee drinks and fruit smoothies, but I think including a section for milkshakes would add an exciting twist to the menu, especially for the summer! People could choose their favorite base flavor and add things to mix in, such as M&Ms, peanuts, cookies, etc.