Made-To-Order Menu

Ice Cream Menu

One of my favorite parts about the MTO menu is the drink section. I love the many different options there are for blended coffee drinks and fruit smoothies, but I think including a section for milkshakes would add an exciting twist to the menu, especially for the summer! People could choose their favorite base flavor and add things to mix in, such as M&Ms, peanuts, cookies, etc.

Submitted by (@rrachaelar)

Voting

219 votes
259 up votes
40 down votes

Made-To-Order Menu

Bagels

I think Sheetz should have a larger selection of bagels to pick from than just a plain bagel. I think many more people would eat breakfast at Sheetz if they were able to pick a blueberry, french toast, egg, everything, onion, or even a cinnamon raisin bagel. It would also be nice to have more cream cheese options such as strawberry, honey nut, or blueberry cream cheese. This selection would entice many more customers ...more »

Submitted by (@skyfooze)

Voting

97 votes
109 up votes
12 down votes

Made-To-Order Menu

MILKSHAKES!

I think that Sheetz should have a MTO option for milkshakes like they have for coffee. Then people could get any flavor of ice cream they wanted in their milkshake and add things like strawberries, bananas, blueberries, or even Oreos and Snickers. I know that many people would love to be able to order milkshakes at Sheetz, and customizing them would be even better.

Submitted by (@skyfooze)

Voting

27 votes
34 up votes
7 down votes

Other Experience Ideas

Food coursing

Can you please course the cold drinks more in time with hot food? There needs to be a way to prevent my cream from getting 59 degrees while it waits for it's fried food companion rung in on same ticket. I know it's a communication issue because lighting quick ice cream dude always looks at me funny when he calls my number and I hesitate to pick up my frozen drink to melt in my hand.

Submitted by (@binkosaurus34)

Voting

2 votes
4 up votes
2 down votes

Self-Serve Coffee

Skim Milk For Self-Serve

I've noticed that many Sheetz are going to whole milk / french vanilla in the liquid dispensers, displacing the skim milk option. While I know there may not be a large need for skim, I feel like this should be at least a request-able option. I was told the MTO skim is ordered based on MTO volume and so any self-serve use would through off the numbers. This means Sheetz is the only coffee place around where skim is ...more »

Submitted by (@brandontidd)

Voting

-1 votes
1 up votes
2 down votes